Who wrote Hamlet? Not up for discussion at the Stratford Festival

Edward de Vere

Nibbling on our breakfast scone at a B & B in Stratford, Ontario last weekend, we were pleased to learn that two of our fellow guests, a couple from Dearborn, Michigan, were fellow Oxfordians. That is, they shared our view that the plays traditionally attributed to William Shakespeare were probably — no one will ever know for sure — written by Edward de Vere, the Earl of Oxford.

This led us to wonder, in turn, how many other Stratford Festival patrons share our irritation every time they open their play programs to find the five canned paragraphs that purport to sum up the life of William Shakespeare.

For most playwrights, biographical blurbs in theater programs have to be greatly condensed. Not so with William Shakespeare. So little is really known about him that at least half of the material about him in the Stratford Festival’s 2008 programs is filler — educated guesses about his life and career. We detect the dramaturge’s struggle for hard facts about the playwright from such speculative phrases as these:

“The exact date of his birth is unknown . . . .”

“[T]radition has it . . . .”

“The young Shakespeare is assumed to have attended what is now the Edward VI Grammar School in Stratford, where he would have studied . . . .”

“Nothing further is known of Shakespeare’s life until 1592 . . . .”

“Possibly as early as 1610, the playwright retired to his home in Stratford-upon-Avon . . . .”

Conspicuously absent from the Stratford Festival’s programs is any hint that this man of whom we know so little may not actually have written The Taming of the Shrew, Romeo and Juliet, Hamlet, and Love’s Labours Lost.

Francis Bacon

But surely the powers-that-be at the Stratford Festival are aware of the issue. And they are surely also aware of the new evidence pointing to Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford, a member of the court of Queen Elizabeth, as the true author — far more evidence, both in quality and in quantity, than was ever brought forward in decades past to support the candidacies of Francis Bacon, Christopher Marlowe, or other Elizabethans.

Emsworth does not complain that the Stratford Festival has not come out in favor of Oxford. This is a matter on which reasonable minds can differ.

As it stands, though, the Stratford Festival is effectively siding with the actor from Stratford. Have the Artistic Director and the dramaturge decided simply to leave things as they are until someone actually produces a draft of Macbeth in Oxford’s handwriting? What will it take for the Stratford Festival to acknowledge that there is at least a serious question as to authorship?

In the meantime, simply ignoring the case for Oxford is not what one might expect from the most influential Shakespeare organization in North America.

Emsworth refers curious readers to the website of the Shakespeare Oxford Society, which outlines the principal reasons to doubt that the actor from Stratford wrote the Shakespeare plays, along with the facts that point to Edward de Vere as the actual poet and playwright. (We are not connected with this organization.) Emsworth has just noticed that Wikipedia now includes an extensive and seemingly objective entry on “Oxfordian theory,” which sets forth arguments both for and against authorship by de Vere.


The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://emsworth.wordpress.com/2008/09/06/who-wrote-hamlet-not-open-for-discussion-at-the-stratford-festival/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

3 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. […] was actually the author of the “Shakespeare” plays and poems.  (See this post, and this one too.)  We think it far more likely that The Winter’s Tale and Hamlet were […]

  2. On November 9, 2008 at 3:13 pm ironhand41 Said: |Edit This
    Your comments on the Shakespeare authorship controversy are welcomed. But informing the issue is difficult because the entrenched academic orthodoxy has subtle ways of silencing those who do their own thinking on the subject. For an excellent expose of this form of censorship read the interview with Dr. Michael Egan, an eminent Shakespearean at http://www.playshakespeare.com/.

  3. Oct. 21, 2008

    Your “nibbling scones at Stratford Shakespeare festive” note came up because I am researching Christopher Marlowe before we go to see EDWARD II at the Chicago Shakespeare Theater Nov 1st. I’ve read several short online bios, suggesting that Marlow (–writing at age 23-29) was “probably” instructing Shakespeare. This assumption works only if the individual you consider as Shakespeare is the one from Stratford.

    In the last 5-6 years, I’ve done some reading about the Authorship Controversy and I also agree it seems eminently logical that Edward DeVere is a more likely candidate.
    The interesting thing is, if you reconsider Marlowe in that light, it stands these bios on their head. I ask myself, how would a young provincial, albeit well-educated, man of about 25 respond to an Earl of Oxford? Especially since around 1589-1591, Edward DeVere was near 40 years old, having by then lost his wife and had his daughters taken by his father-in-law, William Cecil. After returning from the naval battle against the Spanish Armada (–yeah, I know, he sorta missed most of it–), DeVere was living in London– dashing, free-spending, surrounded by stimulating group of young writers.

    Who wrote what….that is still a question. But who influenced whom….that really falls into place if you think the individual using the Shakespeare pseudonym was Edward DeVere.

    Lucinda Foulke
    Elmhurst, IL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: